| Author | Message | ||
Rajusk Legend Username: Rajusk Post Number: 69242 Registered: 02-2008 Posted From: 54.84.30.45 Rating: N/A |
Sixth over of Kings XI's innings, Uthappa fielded the ball at cover, and the Kings XI batsman took a run. But then, when it was fairly clear that the ball was dead (the batsmen were not alive to the possibility of another run, and the fielders were merely passing the ball back to the bowler for the next ball), Uthappa lobbed the ball to Russell at mid-off, who lost it in the floodlights, and ducked, leaving the ball to skip away to the boundary. Ashwin was out of his seat in the dugout straight away, marching to the fourth umpire, making an impassioned case that four overthrows had been conceded. Incredibly, the fourth umpire agreed. He radioed his on-field colleagues, alerted them to Ashwin's complaints, after which the standing umpire signaled four runs. The ball wasn't dead after all. | ||
Cool_indian Side Hero Username: Cool_indian Post Number: 4008 Registered: 02-2008 Posted From: 108.253.242.151 Rating: N/A |
Valid point. If the batsmen is outside the crease when the ball is delivered any runs taken should be deducted. if not, remove the taboo that it is unethical to 'mankad' someone. | ||
Atta_boy Hero Username: Atta_boy Post Number: 14406 Registered: 02-2014 Posted From: 98.193.225.197 Rating: N/A |
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qsZTPrU4JjY I think once you control the man inside of you, the one across from you doesn't really matter. | ||
Sachin Legend Username: Sachin Post Number: 43838 Registered: 04-2008 Posted From: 108.171.133.163 Rating: N/A |
asalu eecaselo butler gadu not at all running..ashwin ball realeasew cheyalsina time ki he was inside the crease...ashwin action stop chesi venakki thrigi stumps ni kottepudu he went out.... | ||
Khaleja Side Hero Username: Khaleja Post Number: 7038 Registered: 09-2009 Posted From: 104.189.156.240 Rating: N/A |
bokkale. ball veyyakunda vaadu legethukupothe adi valid run aa? ala vellipoyi gelisthe adi ethical aa? ila oka 4, 5 times chesthe evadu parigethadu munde. | ||
Mental_sachinodu Megastar Username: Mental_sachinodu Post Number: 22833 Registered: 10-2008 Posted From: 45.26.154.245 Rating: N/A |
that actually makes it worse  .. everytime Ashwin does not runout a batsmen for that margin of being "out of" crease, we can blame ashwin being in cahoots with that batsmend | ||
Confused Comedian Username: Confused Post Number: 1410 Registered: 05-2017 Posted From: 150.148.14.129 Rating: N/A |
Then there has to be some new technology to monitor every ball. Also it becomes boring this way... instead if u have bowler and batting fight for it, it will add one more interesting feature to cricket like baseball. | ||
Musafir Junior Artist Username: Musafir Post Number: 433 Registered: 10-2018 Posted From: 165.225.34.104 Rating: N/A |
https://twitter.com/TheJoshya/status/1110403431364263936 See this tweet. Butler stepped out prior to the ball being released. May be, slow down in judging Ashwin and think about the law for a change. | ||
Mental_sachinodu Megastar Username: Mental_sachinodu Post Number: 22832 Registered: 10-2008 Posted From: 45.26.154.245 Rating: N/A |
in my opinion it should just be counted like an invalid run, similar to how a batsmen loses the run, when he does not cross the crease while going for a single or double. its not much different. | ||
Confused Comedian Username: Confused Post Number: 1408 Registered: 05-2017 Posted From: 99.203.145.79 Rating: N/A |
How about giving a penalty of 5 runs to batting team instead of giving batsman out. | ||
Mental_sachinodu Megastar Username: Mental_sachinodu Post Number: 22831 Registered: 10-2008 Posted From: 45.26.154.245 Rating: N/A |
like i said, everone has their opinion about it. there is a reason its controversial. not all bowlers share the same opinion on it. Walsh would not agree with you, its his choice. | ||
Ringo_rangaswamy Megastar Username: Ringo_rangaswamy Post Number: 22963 Registered: 02-2011 Posted From: 8.36.66.4 Rating: N/A |
May be time to redefine the rules. Why blame players? I know the difference between the spirit of the play and the legal aspects that wont always cover everything. It is batsmans responsibility to determine whether the ball is released or not. In 1987 world cup ( i think), courtney walsh let pakistani runner get away and west indies went out of world cup. Pakistan would have last the game as it was the last wicket. But is that sportsman ship from Walsh. I dont think so. | ||
Mental_sachinodu Megastar Username: Mental_sachinodu Post Number: 22830 Registered: 10-2008 Posted From: 45.26.154.245 Rating: N/A |
All rules are against the wrong doing, but there are situations where player 's spirit comes into play. technically, a bowler can run in and stop before releasing the ball. this is allowed as per rules.. but if a bowler does it 10 times an over, it still under rules, but distracts the batsmen is seen as not within the spirit of the play. Same goes with batsmen, a batsmen can walk away from the stumps right before the ball is delivered, and call for a no ball, and it is within rules. but if a batsmen says, its part of rules, where does the spirit comes in to play? it looks ridiculous. Most players, do not take advantage of such things, although a few bend then every now and then. Thats why Mankading is always controversial. because most batsmen are really going through the motion, they just walk along the bowler, and it is rarely to gain an advantage. if the bowler thinks, the batsmen is taking an advantage, he can clear it with the player. its just a decent thing to do. Again, not saying its bowler's responsibility to let the batsmen know. The same goes with blocking a runner. its not against the rules to block a runner when is trying to reach the crease. but would most players do it? | ||
Ringo_rangaswamy Megastar Username: Ringo_rangaswamy Post Number: 22962 Registered: 02-2011 Posted From: 8.36.66.4 Rating: N/A |
Ilaa aithey every rule is questionable kadaa. Wide balls No balls 1-tup catches catches while touching boundary lines Inka enni question chestaam. Crease lopala undatam batsman responsibility. Vaadu thurruna elthe, out chestaaru. Batsman ball release ayyinda ledaa choodakunda velthe own risk. | ||
Musafir Junior Artist Username: Musafir Post Number: 426 Registered: 10-2018 Posted From: 165.225.34.104 Rating: N/A |
Pant is looking like a million bucks. Evvaru dishti pettakandi. | ||
Rajusk Legend Username: Rajusk Post Number: 69193 Registered: 02-2008 Posted From: 34.201.28.214 Rating: N/A |
3rd umpire goof ups even with DRS soosthunnam kada rao garu. let's not hide behind 3rd umpire for this one.. maa league lo kooda chepparu..last year nunchi..no warning required..eseyyochu ani... | ||
Ringo_rangaswamy Megastar Username: Ringo_rangaswamy Post Number: 22960 Registered: 02-2011 Posted From: 8.36.66.4 Rating: N/A |
3rd umpire out ichaadu antay legal. Inka aagadu ani enti discussion? Aagatam thappaithey, not out ivvaali. | ||
Mental_sachinodu Megastar Username: Mental_sachinodu Post Number: 22829 Registered: 10-2008 Posted From: 45.26.154.245 Rating: N/A |
ikkada jarigindhi adhe vunkl.. Sehwag actually gave up the appeal once against SL .. i remember the bowler was Ashwin, and in that case the batsmen was already warned, and the batsmen still got caught. Even then Sehwag withdrew the appeal, and let the batsmen stay. | ||
Mental_sachinodu Megastar Username: Mental_sachinodu Post Number: 22828 Registered: 10-2008 Posted From: 45.26.154.245 Rating: N/A |
Ashwin offlate has been displaying some traits that are a bit ... "I have an axe to grind" attitude.. i think his omission in multiple formats in team India is rubbing him the wrong ways. in this instance - Apparently there was pre-season call to discuss exactly this, by team captains, and it was agreed upon that there wont be mankading in IPL. IPL clearly broke the agreement - also the play was very doubtful. batsmen being out of the crease is not a violation. Anyway - its a crazy rule. all other rules are enforced by umpires, while this particular rule is sort of enforced by bowlers, and each bowler has his opinion on this. | ||
Rajusk Legend Username: Rajusk Post Number: 69191 Registered: 02-2008 Posted From: 34.201.28.214 Rating: N/A |
Once bowler starts run up..at a given speed of stride, you would expect it would continue..(just giving benefit of doubt to Butler anthe) and ball gets delivered.. | ||
Musafir Junior Artist Username: Musafir Post Number: 424 Registered: 10-2018 Posted From: 165.225.34.104 Rating: N/A |
Meanwhile, Dhawan is playing blindfolded. Guddi oopudu endira rey pich nayala... World cup lo aadalsinodivi. | ||
Musafir Junior Artist Username: Musafir Post Number: 423 Registered: 10-2018 Posted From: 165.225.34.104 Rating: N/A |
Aren't they missing a point? Butler isn't looking at Ashwin. There is no way he knows if he is moving before or after a ball is released. | ||
Rajusk Legend Username: Rajusk Post Number: 69190 Registered: 02-2008 Posted From: 34.201.28.214 Rating: N/A |
adi matter..anduke kummuthunnar | ||
Musafir Junior Artist Username: Musafir Post Number: 422 Registered: 10-2018 Posted From: 165.225.34.104 Rating: N/A |
How do you know? He wasn't even looking at the bowler. | ||
Film_fan Legend Username: Film_fan Post Number: 34434 Registered: 03-2008 Posted From: 62.253.209.120 Rating: N/A |
mmm..debatable..... but lines are there for a reason......a great striker always want to be on strike....and a lead before the delivery is bowled...rotates the strike a bit easier.... agree with the warning......but.....bowlers and batsman giving warning to each other.....is not the way.....rules are set..... If bowler is penalised....for inch long.....batsman should be penalised for inch short..... still avoidable.... We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence, then, is not an act, but a habit. -- Aristotle | ||
Bharat Side Hero Username: Bharat Post Number: 7495 Registered: 06-2015 Posted From: 149.168.240.7 Rating: N/A |
Butler was not trying to gain unfair advantage.....he waited until the baller was in his stride......bad decision by Ashwin | ||
Vipersting Junior Artist Username: Vipersting Post Number: 378 Registered: 09-2018 Posted From: 12.132.212.82 Rating: N/A |
Warning is not at all needed guys. Rule book also removed it. Spirit of the game ani topic divert avutundi. If Butler was really out of his crease at the time of delivery, Ashwin would've been totally correct in what he did. BUT he stopped and waited for Butler to go out. That's unsportsmanlike. | ||
Ringo_rangaswamy Megastar Username: Ringo_rangaswamy Post Number: 22959 Registered: 02-2011 Posted From: 8.36.66.4 Rating: N/A |
50 yard boundaries free hit one bouncer per over 2 power plays in 20 overs fielder restrictions outside the circle Too much disrespect to bowlers and and cricket converted to circus show. Natural ga Ashwin as bowler/captain explored his options with in legal limit. Perfect. | ||
Musafir Junior Artist Username: Musafir Post Number: 421 Registered: 10-2018 Posted From: 165.225.34.104 Rating: N/A |
I think he should keep doing this every game until the law changes or says it is acceptable. Stop this harakiri once and for all. | ||
Ringo_rangaswamy Megastar Username: Ringo_rangaswamy Post Number: 22958 Registered: 02-2011 Posted From: 8.36.66.4 Rating: N/A |
Competitive level lo out kaakunda chooskotam batsman responsibility. Wicket keeper batsman ki stumping chestaa nuvvu outside crease velli batting chestunnaavu ani cheppadu kadhaa. Suppose aa batsman comes out of crease in the last of of the world cup champion ship when batting team needs 1 run. So single kotti championship kavali ani runner mundhey raavatam unfair kadhaa. Game is played by rules. Sportsmanship can be appreciated but cannot be demanded. | ||
Rajusk Legend Username: Rajusk Post Number: 69189 Registered: 02-2008 Posted From: 34.201.28.214 Rating: N/A |
Warning is a courtesy rao garu anthe.. giving benefit of doubt..to feeful who inadvertently walk out.. anduke anna serial offender aithe..warning ichi ..then will go for it ani.. | ||
Cool_indian Side Hero Username: Cool_indian Post Number: 4005 Registered: 02-2008 Posted From: 108.253.242.151 Rating: N/A |
Very unsportsman like by Ashwin. No warning Very deliberate Ofcourse by rules it is out if the bowler appeals. Captain revert cheyyali ethically. Kaani ikkada chesindi edava captain | ||
Atta_boy Hero Username: Atta_boy Post Number: 14405 Registered: 02-2014 Posted From: 166.137.90.16 Rating: N/A |
Raaju saab... third umpire messed up.. alright.. Let's say ashwin mankaded without stopping action abd did it right away.... appud then why warning needed?... yee lekanna this ball will spin ani kuda warning ivvalna batsmen ki.. I think once you control the man inside of you, the one across from you doesn't really matter. | ||
Ringo_rangaswamy Megastar Username: Ringo_rangaswamy Post Number: 22957 Registered: 02-2011 Posted From: 172.58.184.126 Rating: N/A |
What is yourr reason for giving a warning? | ||
Rajusk Legend Username: Rajusk Post Number: 69187 Registered: 02-2008 Posted From: 172.56.37.42 Rating: N/A |
As a bowler myself..I would at least warn the batsman.. That is my way of dealing with regular offenders | ||
Ringo_rangaswamy Megastar Username: Ringo_rangaswamy Post Number: 22955 Registered: 02-2011 Posted From: 172.58.184.126 Rating: N/A |
Asalu itlaa out cheyyatM game spirit ki against ani start chesi a yedhava evado! Batsman alert ga undaali. Vaadu lagethukuntoo poyi single theeste count ainappudu, same batsman start lo careful ga the undaali. Ashiwin gaadu manchi pani chesadu. | ||
Termi Hero Username: Termi Post Number: 12115 Registered: 01-2012 Posted From: 206.201.77.161 Rating: N/A |
i support Ashwin and all YCP fans would also support it Hardcore Prabhas raju fan | ||
Raman Legend Username: Raman Post Number: 61947 Registered: 01-2009 Posted From: 171.76.54.149 Rating: N/A |
3rd umpire role emi ledu batsmen bayata unda lopata unda anthe | ||
Sachin Legend Username: Sachin Post Number: 43837 Registered: 04-2008 Posted From: 8.25.28.233 Rating: N/A |
ethics and all pakkana pettinaaa, 3rd umpire did blunder. that was not out.... | ||
Raman Legend Username: Raman Post Number: 61946 Registered: 01-2009 Posted From: 171.76.54.149 Rating: N/A |
Ocean 7 batsmen Ki levva stumping outs run outs maree sebutavu. Fast bowler at140 Oka adugu munduku vachi beamer este ettauntado telsa?. Batsmen has advantage anuko in general but .. Aswin gadu chesindi edavapani Daniki rules Ni lagadam tappy | ||
Oceanseven Side Hero Username: Oceanseven Post Number: 9770 Registered: 09-2008 Posted From: 73.129.141.33 Rating: N/A |
correct/ethical ani cheppanu kaanee, paapam bowlers ball vesthey, line entha dhaataadu ani check cheyyatam, edho crime chesinattu next ball free hit anatam, edho sadism lekka vundhi chethi lo nundi ball release avvakamundhey batsman geetha dhaatithey aah ball ki no run ani kooda pettaali, and next ball entha kottinaa zero runs ani pettaali too much harsh rules vunnai bowlers ki | ||
Gochi Side Hero Username: Gochi Post Number: 4018 Registered: 12-2006 Posted From: 64.121.67.210 Rating: N/A |
Kapil Dev did the same thing with Peter Kristen back in 1992...but before doing this he reported this to the umpire 3 times and umpire warned the batsmen he is going out of crease...and finally fourth time he did mankading...and it was done in a proper way on the way he was releasing the ball..Ashwin asalu warning kooda ivvakundaa chesunte its not fair... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8pSPJoWic7A | ||
Enigmatic Side Hero Username: Enigmatic Post Number: 2258 Registered: 11-2010 Posted From: 69.249.71.186 Rating: N/A |
emi chesadu | ||
Musafir Junior Artist Username: Musafir Post Number: 418 Registered: 10-2018 Posted From: 73.136.80.68 Rating: N/A |
Papam family ni target chestunnaru insta lo. Useless fellows Cheater's daughter, cheater's wife anukuntu. Disgusting social media warriors. | ||
Dhonifan Megastar Username: Dhonifan Post Number: 20402 Registered: 12-2012 Posted From: 72.193.103.35 Rating: N/A |
adaithey disgusting | ||
Musafir Junior Artist Username: Musafir Post Number: 417 Registered: 10-2018 Posted From: 73.136.80.68 Rating: N/A |
Johnty Rhodes to worst argument. Joke edi serious edi telidu metta gadiki. But aa runout vishayam lo third umpire made a mistake and the law needs to be changed. | ||
Rahul Moderator Username: Rahul Post Number: 8499 Registered: 12-2010 Rating: |
ee Ashwin gadu too worst ..monnativarku off field, twitter lo too bad behaviour ippudu on field kuda Ee Sala Cup Namde | ||
Dhonifan Megastar Username: Dhonifan Post Number: 20401 Registered: 12-2012 Posted From: 72.193.103.35 Rating: N/A |
even as per rules it was not out. see the rule I have posted in first post | ||
Dhonifan Megastar Username: Dhonifan Post Number: 20400 Registered: 12-2012 Posted From: 72.193.103.35 Rating: N/A |
Lisa Sthalekar âVerified account @sthalekar93 1h1 hour ago Hereâs my 2 cents worth on THE run out. Should have been called dead ball cause at the point of release â¬ï¸ Buttler is in, but Ashwin waits until his momentum of âbacking upâ takes him out of the crease. | ||
Rbreddy Junior Artist Username: Rbreddy Post Number: 931 Registered: 02-2008 Posted From: 124.182.8.248 Rating: N/A |
It was out as per the rules. But was it ethical? Debatable | ||
Vipersting Junior Artist Username: Vipersting Post Number: 377 Registered: 09-2018 Posted From: 12.132.212.82 Rating: N/A |
Poor strategy from Ashwin and a Blunder from the 3rd umpire to give it out. | ||
Dhonifan Megastar Username: Dhonifan Post Number: 20387 Registered: 12-2012 Posted From: 72.193.103.35 Rating: N/A |
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/D2hhmgHWsAAU3an.jpg ashwin ga, when you stopped your bowling action, butler was not even out of the crease. its not even within the rules. 3rd umpire should have caught it. it is out only if he is out of the exprease by the time ball is expected to bowl. ball was expected to bowl when he was in the crease, but ashwin withdrew from the action. at that time jos was in the crease |
