| Author | Message | ||
     Time_pass Side Hero Username: Time_pass Post Number: 5758 Registered: 06-2008 Posted From: 216.52.207.123 Rating: N/A |
// ayina hinduism ni ekkuva annadu, islam ni touch cheyyaleddu ani matalu enduku... // idol worshp wrong ane point choopinchali ante mari Mecca lo oka raayi chuttu tirige oka piece choopincha vachhu ga leka local mosque lo oka nalla raayi ki mokkatam choopincha vachhu ga | ||
| Time_pass Side Hero Username: Time_pass Post Number: 5757 Registered: 06-2008 Posted From: 216.52.207.123 Rating: N/A |
// enduku chinchukuntunnav meharu? entertainment ni entrtainment ga soodandi mesharoo, // ee lavado lo logic prakaram Book ni Book ga choooda vachhu ga adi Tasleema raasina , Rashdie raasina alage Kamal cinema ki enduku antha nuisance Cartoon ni Cartoon ga teesu ko vachhu ga, manushulani champala ikkada dissent ante ne anth poduchu kostundi ee mofo commi, Nehru & descendants gallu sickularism meaning e maarela brain wash chesi dobbaru | ||
| Thikka_sankara Hero Username: Thikka_sankara Post Number: 17049 Registered: 02-2012 Posted From: 106.208.44.196 Rating: N/A |
talk about India, and yes pattinchukunnaru.... Davinchi kodu ni proactive gaa ban chesaaru..... keka link: fikileaks, | ||
| Lolligadu Side Hero Username: Lolligadu Post Number: 7616 Registered: 09-2012 Posted From: 117.235.206.239 Rating: N/A |
holly lo christianity ni criticize sesthar, jesus ni boothulu thidtar evadu ayina pattinchukunnara? jews ni valla religion ni kindal sethar, adi movie varake danni attane soodali ani naa peeling. | ||
| Thikka_sankara Hero Username: Thikka_sankara Post Number: 17048 Registered: 02-2012 Posted From: 106.208.44.196 Rating: N/A |
Assalu don't bring malala into picture, nowhere she is against Islam, she spoke out against a group of oppressors who are depriving children the basic education..... She nowhere criticised Islam Taslima ni oppose chesina vaallaki pk ni oppose chese vallaki commonality eppudosthundi ante, when someone from pk opposers try physical harm to pk/hirani.... Theater vandalism ani chepoddu, that'd be similar to bookstall vandalism....not with physical assaults on taslima.... keka link: fikileaks, | ||
| Kingaa_bongaa Hero Username: Kingaa_bongaa Post Number: 18978 Registered: 02-2008 Posted From: 199.207.253.101 Rating: N/A |
kanipinchina raayi ni mokkatam lo naaku confusion ledhu, aa bokka bokadia gaadu evadu naaku cheppataaniki? ika pothe irks me, nee mistake kaadhu, its clearly PK mistake. andhuke PK ni dobbuthunnaam. madhyalo nuvvu vachi naa mistake kaadhu antunnaav. kyaaa thamuduuu?  Manaki Manam Kingu, Choosevallaki Bongu. | ||
| Lolligadu Side Hero Username: Lolligadu Post Number: 7615 Registered: 09-2012 Posted From: 117.235.206.239 Rating: N/A |
asalu pk choosava, dantlo god ledu ani cheppada? practicing religion in this way is wrong ani cheppadaa like OMG. Practicing religion lo too much confusion undi.....danni clarity tho cheppaledu anthey. if that irks most of the ppl like you its not my mistake. | ||
| Thikka_sankara Hero Username: Thikka_sankara Post Number: 17047 Registered: 02-2012 Posted From: 106.208.44.196 Rating: N/A |
obvious gaa antaaru.... Becoz of multiple reasons 1) movie paranga choosukunte, hero is an alien.... If he wants criticize custom practices of worship, then, as an outsider, he should have criticized custom practices of all religions on equal scale.... By predominantly criticizing only Hindu practices and unwarrantly giving conduct certificates of people of other religions, movie stood out 2) movie paranga kaakunda, outside factors choosthe, too often than not, any movies remotely attempting a satire on other religions are getting serious scrutiny, whereas, movies criticizing hinduism alone are passing thru taking the cover of art/fiction blah blah blah So, obviously people would start questioning at some point right? keka link: fikileaks, | ||
| Lolligadu Side Hero Username: Lolligadu Post Number: 7614 Registered: 09-2012 Posted From: 117.235.206.239 Rating: N/A |
http://www.chalanachithram.com/cgi-bin/discus/show.cgi?tpc=1 15&post=4832752#POST4832752
poni ee okkati cheppandi mesharooo pk ni bash chesevalla tho reason cheyyakudadu ani okka mata seppandi moosuku kursunta  | ||
| Kingaa_bongaa Hero Username: Kingaa_bongaa Post Number: 18977 Registered: 02-2008 Posted From: 199.207.253.101 Rating: N/A |
LOL. OMG choosavaa asalu? god vunnaaadu ane choopinchaadu. Godmen are wrong ani choopinchaadu, which most of us agree. inkedainaaa comparision theeskuraaa. Manaki Manam Kingu, Choosevallaki Bongu. | ||
| Lolligadu Side Hero Username: Lolligadu Post Number: 7613 Registered: 09-2012 Posted From: 117.235.206.239 Rating: N/A |
criticize chesey dantlone reason ledu. whole concept ni anochu kani islam ni ekkuva anledu hindus ni annaru ani simple balance lo petti soodatm endi/ pk ni antey annadi kani aa thought process lo unna normal junta emi chesaru. it is similar to saying that whole Islam is evil. | ||
| Thikka_sankara Hero Username: Thikka_sankara Post Number: 17046 Registered: 02-2012 Posted From: 106.208.44.196 Rating: N/A |
what's your precise point of content.tion.... Eee thread lo first post direct tasleema antoo comparision tho ochaavu.... keka link: fikileaks, | ||
| Lolligadu Side Hero Username: Lolligadu Post Number: 7612 Registered: 09-2012 Posted From: 117.235.206.239 Rating: N/A |
varusuga roju pk ni bash chesthunnaru... okkaroju koda disco loki enter kaledu ala criticize cheyyataki vallaku ri8s unnayi kabbatti. kani eeroju aa thought process lo unnollu andarini anteney reply ichanu. evil intentions untey charities lativi enduku chestharu . comprehension problems untey nenem cheyyagalanu. | ||
| Thikka_sankara Hero Username: Thikka_sankara Post Number: 17045 Registered: 02-2012 Posted From: 106.208.44.196 Rating: N/A |
the same objection 'some people's are having against pk movie....konni points ni addu pettukuni motham Hindu way of worship ni thappu ante correct kaaadu anipinche criticise chesthunnaru.... Movies cannot duck behind the cover of fiction..... Movies are a powerful medium that influences masses.... Movies ki social responsibilities akkarledu they are just fiction ante inka censor board enduku??? keka link: fikileaks, | ||
| Lolligadu Side Hero Username: Lolligadu Post Number: 7611 Registered: 09-2012 Posted From: 117.235.206.239 Rating: N/A |
fiction ni addupettukoni adey thought process lo unna migatha andarini vplu anteney correct kadu anipinchindi. ala annavallanu mathrame edupu antunnanu kinda nunsi saduvu babai. | ||
| Thikka_sankara Hero Username: Thikka_sankara Post Number: 17044 Registered: 02-2012 Posted From: 106.208.44.196 Rating: N/A |
lol fiction ni criticize cheyyadam eppudu choodaleda?? Ide first time choosthunnava.... Poni fiction criticise cheyyadam pointless anukunte vallani 'edvadam' ani nuvvenduku edusthunnav?? Anyway, ikkada just fiction ni kaaadu, aaa fiction ni create chesina vaalla intentions ni criticise chesthunnaru.... If it means anything to you keka link: fikileaks, | ||
| Lolligadu Side Hero Username: Lolligadu Post Number: 7610 Registered: 09-2012 Posted From: 117.235.206.239 Rating: N/A |
asalu fiction criticize cheyyatam endi, time bokka and blood boiling thappithey. eduddamu anukuneyvadini etta aputham annai... vishayam chepthunna anthey. | ||
| Thikka_sankara Hero Username: Thikka_sankara Post Number: 17042 Registered: 02-2012 Posted From: 106.208.44.196 Rating: N/A |
Ohh ippudu ela criticize cheyyalo evarni cheyyalo dictate chestaara.... Lol keka link: fikileaks, | ||
| Lolligadu Side Hero Username: Lolligadu Post Number: 7609 Registered: 09-2012 Posted From: 117.235.206.239 Rating: N/A |
criticize cheyyandi cheyyoddu ani evau annaru, champion ga amish gadini attukosthene comedy anipinchindi. ayina hinduism ni ekkuva annadu, islam ni touch cheyyaleddu ani matalu enduku... whole concept and narration wrong ani edavachu kada. | ||
| Thikka_sankara Hero Username: Thikka_sankara Post Number: 17038 Registered: 02-2012 Posted From: 106.208.44.196 Rating: N/A |
if ak and hirani have the right to criticize hinduism and it's faults, we too have a right to criticize their movie and it's faults....enduku intha chinna point miss ayyi Gila Gila kottukuntunnaru movie nachinollandaru....lol keka link: fikileaks, | ||
| Lolligadu Side Hero Username: Lolligadu Post Number: 7608 Registered: 09-2012 Posted From: 117.235.206.239 Rating: N/A |
naku anumanamenduku annai. my knowledge permits me to think rationally. with my previous statement what i meant was for every conflict/disco each side will have a logical reason. in this particular case lastavatar unkul is fighting with fiction which is waste and useless. adi okkate kakunda same thought process lo unnavallandaru vplu ayipothara? pk also blurts out its side of logic without much thinking and research. anyways i am wasting my time reasoning with ppl who are measuring religion with fiction. it looks like i am rooting for pk, actually which i am not. PK's thought process does concur with atleast quarter of our population.so just waving it off/ bashing it is wrong ani naa feeling. | ||
| Happyguy415 Junior Artist Username: Happyguy415 Post Number: 46 Registered: 01-2014 Posted From: 107.223.208.185 Rating: N/A |
so called "message oriented" movies ni pattukuni "fiction" ani kotti paarestaavu emiti annai?
OMG soodale  - nenu nammagalige naa friends cheppinadi vinna daani prakaaram, OMG lo questioning looks appealing, with some conclusions in the end. But this movie is pathetic in that sense | ||
| Lolligadu Side Hero Username: Lolligadu Post Number: 7607 Registered: 09-2012 Posted From: 117.235.206.239 Rating: N/A |
adi fiction annai... milk and chaddar(blankets) rendu cheppadu kada....ayina fiction lo logic ni measure cheyyatam endi annai? pk pedda boku synma... dantho reason chesedemi ledu... chala movies lo police ni pedda bukulla choopistharu... vallu aa movies meda war ki vellali antava? reel ni real ni mix cheyyatam waste. | ||
| Lolligadu Side Hero Username: Lolligadu Post Number: 7606 Registered: 09-2012 Posted From: 117.235.206.239 Rating: N/A |
amish gadu hindu kabatti vadini kochen cheyyaledu....aamir muz ayipoyadu kabatti ee racha ani naa feeling.... OMG lo ive cheppina akshay and paresh ki same logic apply cheyyaledu enduku anedi naa question annai... | ||
| Happyguy415 Junior Artist Username: Happyguy415 Post Number: 45 Registered: 01-2014 Posted From: 107.223.208.185 Rating: N/A |
annai, neeku anumaanamu unte, prasninchu....that is what "Sanatana Dharmam" encourages people. as movie makers - they have access to a lot of resources, so they should do proper research and show only those rituals that do not have any proper reasoning behind following them. But bashing even the most basic things is super duper bad. If you do not see that point, I am sorry to say, you are wasting your time in this thread  | ||
| Raman Legend Username: Raman Post Number: 34842 Registered: 01-2009 Posted From: 192.251.134.5 Rating: N/A |
endi adi oka entertainment aa? asala aliens chala iq takkuva annattu chuparu .. Second asala oka matanni touch cheste blasphemy ani oka 10 fatwas vastayi debbaki hirani kurradu and aamir blast ayyetollu . He is saying spending on 10 rupees milk abhishekam is bad it shd be given to the poor? deenemma haz yathraki enta kharchu avasaram anna question cheyyagaligada? Kaneesam end lo blast ki tellals meeda chinna class ayina peekagaligada? Asala venakki tirigi chuste pedda entertainment kuda ledu .. charlie chaplin lekka old style undi konchem Anyways author is ok with criticism .. he is responding to the criticism anthe .. gudimundu vigrahalu poolu kobbari kayalu ammetollaki pratyamnyam chupinchali kada first pichinayalu entered the temple and church with helmet on kakapote maseedu anagane kerchief ettukuni ready ayyadu .. ayina vimarsa ni vimarsa ga teeskondi meerukooda | ||
| Happyguy415 Junior Artist Username: Happyguy415 Post Number: 44 Registered: 01-2014 Posted From: 107.223.208.185 Rating: N/A |
annai, aa triology nenu chadavaledu. kaani ee article baagundi. Ayite, ippudu baagunna daaniki mechchukovaddu antaavaa? | ||
| Lolligadu Side Hero Username: Lolligadu Post Number: 7604 Registered: 09-2012 Posted From: 117.235.206.239 Rating: N/A |
eedebba ee amish gadu pk gurunchi critical ga rasadani eedini highlight sethunnaru mari eedi shiva triology lo asalu god aney concept ne question chesadu..  | ||
| Lolligadu Side Hero Username: Lolligadu Post Number: 7603 Registered: 09-2012 Posted From: 117.235.206.239 Rating: |
enduku chinchukuntunnav meharu? entertainment ni entrtainment ga soodandi mesharoo, why try to logic with the fiction. PK neither questioned god nor his existence... it touched the nuances and subtleties in polytheism and idol worship.... nuvvu ramudini nammuthavu kada? ramudu okkate banam, okkate mata n okate pathni annadu mari polygamy follow avuthunna pk ki enduku fanism sethunnav. nenu taslemma ni malala ni teesukochindi enduku antey they questioned muzs faith and their practices. ippudu pk ni question chesthunna vallaki tas and malala mathram correct hirani and vidhuvinod chopra wrong etla avutharu deenemma dabbulu kosam cinema lo oka egspression fedithey danni pak meda love ga convert sesava? lol. satyamevajayathe and charity chesina adey aamir gurthuledaaa???? pk does concur with the thought process of atleast 25% of hindu population who question the same... allandaru vplu aipothara???? endo le nee gola.... neekanna artham avuthundo ledo nee logic. | ||
| Nice Side Hero Username: Nice Post Number: 8999 Registered: 05-2009 Posted From: 122.164.19.170 Rating: N/A |
 | ||
| Ruj Hero Username: Ruj Post Number: 15649 Registered: 03-2007 Posted From: 24.118.14.4 Rating: N/A |
awesome..KUmmeasdu... This is the right way to express dissent and show the makers their place.. | ||
| Last_avataar Side Hero Username: Last_avataar Post Number: 4400 Registered: 09-2012 Posted From: 12.10.219.227 Rating: |
Entertainment ante noru musukuni daani meeda focus pettali Verri poo yesalu esi ... oka faith meede toomuch focus pettadam kaadu Last scene lo pak gurinchi matladutu... Amir gaadu moham too much emotions. Oka align ki antha avasarama... Nuvu pedda medhavi kada... maaku movie suddam kooda radu neelaga Neelontllaki paapm Janalani sAMPESE VOLLU aapadaru For your Information we are protesting not trying to eliminate people - Malala and Taslima are physically attacked. Nee lantollaki noruu kooda padipotundi, ekkadayiba edo jarigite India lo vidvamsam. Appudu mee lanti metavulu noru kuttukuntaru Neeku cinema nachite enjoy. Ante kaani don't try to question others knowledge Half backed knowledge to movies teeste neeku entertainment kavochu Kaani Hinduism ABC lu teliyani vallu comments cheste ne worst gauntundi | ||
| Lolligadu Side Hero Username: Lolligadu Post Number: 7602 Registered: 09-2012 Posted From: 117.235.206.239 Rating: N/A |
i am amazed at intelligence of some who are trying to question n logic a entertainment form which is not even accessible to 20% of the nation. why didn't these intellectuals show their solidarity to the Muslims who rallied against tasleema for lazza. malala right aamir wrong, tasleema right hirani wrong bemmandamaina logic  | ||
| Last_avataar Side Hero Username: Last_avataar Post Number: 4398 Registered: 09-2012 Posted From: 12.10.219.227 Rating: |
Chala Mandi Hirani and Aamir Lanti PP laki telavadu - Hindu Idol worship lo, we don't treat object as god. But we select a right material and invite god to that , before starting pooja. - Veeri puvu Aamir gadu - Mecca kelli pradashina chestadu, eedga goda mundu namaz chestadu, mari gudi voddu annodu, meeku masque lu enduku ra.. lafoot Aamir - Gallone pooja chesuko, Mosquelu anni koola dobbu Hirani gaadu oka vp ayite Amir gaadu oka peeda fraud nayalu. Donga Kannellu pettukoni TV shows cheyyatam kaadu Yedava. This is your last success. Tare jamin per chusina tarvatha vochina respect pportiga naakichavu. Nuvu pedda hyped actor nenu eppudo cheppanu. Hirani gadu pedda intelli fellow laaga cutting | ||
| Kadapanagfan Legend Username: Kadapanagfan Post Number: 57049 Registered: 12-2006 Posted From: 103.246.197.12 Rating: N/A |
Gopala Gopala release yeppudu???? | ||
| ~chirutha~ Side Hero Username: ~chirutha~ Post Number: 2213 Registered: 10-2011 Posted From: 59.145.137.97 Rating: N/A |
Nice article. Kani em labham PK made it big thanks to the controversies around it. Ilanti cinemalani neglect chesthene better. Be Kool  | ||
| Awara1984 Side Hero Username: Awara1984 Post Number: 2921 Registered: 12-2010 Posted From: 125.16.29.3 Rating: |
I am not suggesting that idol-rejecting cultures are bad; there are strengths and qualities in them; weaknesses as well. Similarly, there are weaknesses among the idol-worshipping. But there is one immeasurably precious quality that they possess; which is the secret to their inherent liberalism. Surprisingly this is precisely what is portrayed in PK as a weakness viz: That idol-worshippers are open to worshipping anything, even a stone. What is the philosophical idea that underpins this attitude? Why are we willing to worship anything? Because this might lead us to see the divine in everything. There is nothing in this world that is not divine or Godly. This gives someone like me the philosophical grounding to worship Gods/symbols of all faiths. It gives us the philosophical grounding to be able to love and respect everyone, even those among the idol-rejecters who hate us simply because we worship idols. Because we see God in them as well. This gives us the ability to respect nature and the environment with religious zeal, since we don’t believe that nature was created for our use, but that it is God! What transforms a stone into God? Our belief does it. Can this belief be exploited? Possibly. But, if, as shown in the movie, someone prays to a stone, and if this gives them hope, then what exactly is the problem? Hope is one of the greatest human strengths. And how is worshipping a stone different from someone visiting a temple with an officially recognised idol, or a mosque or a church? You will think there is a difference only if you believe God doesn’t exist everywhere. If, like me, you’re a nature and idol-worshipper, you will find that God exists everywhere. In you, in me, in animals, in trees and, yes, even in that stone in the movie PK. | ||
| Awara1984 Side Hero Username: Awara1984 Post Number: 2920 Registered: 12-2010 Posted From: 125.16.29.3 Rating: N/A |
Consider another ‘hard-hitting’ scene in the movie. The protagonist picks up a rock, applies paan masala on it, and says that soon this will become God which everyone will worship. The subtext is clear: Look at these idol-worshipping idiots who will worship anything. Don’t they realise that this is not the real God, who apparently is an ‘external’ entity? This belief that idol-worshipping is somehow wrong, or at least primitive and tribal, has been around for long. However, few are able to give a cogent, theological answer as to why it’s wrong; except one that you can’t argue with: ‘My God said so!’ Over the last two millennia, some communities, starting with the Europeans, then the Arabs, Turks, Mongols etc, took this dislike to an extreme level to end the ‘Satanic’ idol-worshipping practice forcibly. There was massive violence across the world to purge idol-worship. Many places of worship were destroyed, others appropriated, and millions of people slaughtered simply because they worshipped idols. The ancient world was dotted with idol-worshipping cultures. But today, most of them — the Hellenic, Khemit, etc — have been exterminated. Hinduism is a rare idol-worshipping culture that has survived. Interestingly, I have not come across many historical examples of idol-worshipping cultures going around the world, killing ‘others’ simply because they were not worshipping idols. | ||
| Awara1984 Side Hero Username: Awara1984 Post Number: 2919 Registered: 12-2010 Posted From: 125.16.29.3 Rating: N/A |
PK is clearly making ‘rational’ arguments against those who love myths, follow living spiritual masters (rather than exclusively prophets/messiahs who lived many centuries ago) and worship idols. You may imagine that only Hinduism answers to this description. You would be wrong. Idol-worshipping cultures proliferated across the world in the ancient era; and most encouraged questioning. Nothing was beyond the pale of criticism because they didn’t believe in only ‘one’ truth. Certainly there are features of Hinduism that can and should be critically examined. But it’s intriguing that the makers of PK thought it fit to criticise some strengths of idol-worshipping cultures instead. The fact that idol-worshipping cultures, normally, have living spiritual masters allows them to change easily in times of fast change. Reform is, normally, easier for such cultures and you will find that among them, philosophies change relatively smoothly with changing times. Admittedly, there are some unsavoury elements among the present-day spiritual masters. But the ‘Muslim terrorist’, the ‘paedophile Western Catholic priest’ and the ‘unscrupulous idol-worshipping godman’ have a common thread — they all suffer from the fallacy of stereotyping. Maybe I’m naive, but one expects intelligent filmmakers to be nuanced enough to not stereotype. | ||
| Awara1984 Side Hero Username: Awara1984 Post Number: 2918 Registered: 12-2010 Posted From: 125.16.29.3 Rating: N/A |
Let’s use the same Freedom of Expression standards to pose some questions to the filmmakers of PK. Clearly, PK is a noble attempt to convince us that naked, humanoid aliens regularly visit India and they can educate us on our relationship with God. In this same spirit of scientific inquiry, PK casts some serious doubts on religion. Actually, not all religions; some have been covered perfunctorily. The primary scholarly analysis is on religions that practise idol-worship (note that, theologically, practically all idol-worshippers are also nature-worshippers, for that is the philosophical route). | ||
| Awara1984 Side Hero Username: Awara1984 Post Number: 2917 Registered: 12-2010 Posted From: 125.16.29.3 Rating: N/A |
http://www.hindustantimes.com/news-feed/amish/beliefs-may-be -cast-in-stone/article1-1304390.aspx |
